John Edward Binnion: 24: Gen. Patton's Staff, Operation Husky, Sicily


 "... it's a darn cinch we're going to need 
every soldier or would-be soldier before long." 
John Edward in letter home (full letter below), April 5, 1943, family scan
 

Final preparations were underway for the next campaign, 
code-named Operation Husky. While plans were still top secret,
  it was inevitable that the Allied Forces would soon head toward Europe:
In July, the Allies would invade Sicily and 
pave the way for invasion of Italy and then Europe.

Gen Montgomery & Gen Patton review a map of Sicily, August-July 1943, Navy photo 
 

As previously seen during such times of transition, letters home 
were
 sprinkled with special requests and instructions, 
and often included some financial support. 

 John Edward wrote his mom that the Valentine card she sent 
was "really something. This old heart of mine very seldom gets sentimental, 
but today it got pretty close to it." 
 He concluded: 
"But sentiment is something we have very little of over here."

  

He also sent some poker winnings from games 
he "got into in a few odd moments,"
along with encouragement to 
"go out and buy yourself some new duds and stuff, 
and show 'em what a glamour girl really is."

"There's nothing to spend your money for over here," he added,
and we're all of the opinion that 'you can't take it with you' 
unless you are going back to the States.
"   


Meanwhile, fifty-five DUKWs had been sent to North Africa 
for examination, review, and training.
These newly developed 6x6 amphibious vehicles could
 operate seamlessly between water and land. 

Friend of John Edward inspecting underside of  a DUKW, 1943-44, family scan

A driver would no longer have to exit the vehicle to change operation
 between propeller and wheels or to adjust tire pressure (on each tire)
 for better traction on sand or higher speeds on land.
During a beachhead invasion, these vehicles could transport 
more men and supplies quicker and safer. 
 

Letter home, March 22, 1943, family scan

"I'm really sold on DUKWs, and as far as I'm concerned, I'll be content 
to finish out the rest of my time over here with them .... I've finally 
got to know the men [in his company] sufficiently well to operate 
in a pretty efficient manner -- and that takes time, and a 
change would mean going through all that again." 

 

These March 22 and April 6 letters were microfilmed 
onto V-Mail, (short for Victory Mail). 
Developed to make better use of cargo space, about 150,000
 V-Mails could be sent in one bag -- rather than 
the 37 bags required for paper letters. 

John Edward letter home, April 6, 1943, family scan


  In April, John Edward wrote that he had again been hospitalized 

"with the same back injury that I had in December -- there 
was some sort of a rupture in the "shock absorbers" between the 
vertebrae -- and they offered me a chance to go back to the States. 

"Erstwhile refused .... it's a darn cinch we're going to need 
every soldier or would-be soldier before long." 

He added:
"By the way, there is one thing I wish you would do -- you, and probably no one else, 
will be informed in case anything happens to me."

He gave Virginia Murray's address in Brooklyn so that she might be informed.
"Otherwise, there is no occasion to write.
Remember that--don't write unless something happens."

 

Port Pass for John Edward, April 12, 1943, family scan.

A few days later 
he was 
back at work. 

 The Port Pass 
for "Duty in Port Area" 
recorded his unit: 
"138th Q.M.Co. Truck."  

 

 

However, he would soon receive orders from Gen. Patton 
to serve as a Staff Officer.

John Edward ephemera regarding his promotion to 1st Lt.  The designation G-4 
was used when he served on Gen. Patton's staff in N Africa and Sicily. 1943, family scan.
 
John Edward explained:
it was the "convoy service moving troops from the West Coast of Africa 
to the fighting area [in Tunisia] that caused me to be
requested by name to serve in a special planning unit."

 This new assignment came with a promotion to 1st Lt.  

John Edward letter home, May 1943, family scan

The "mopping-up," as concluding operations were called, 
was largely completed in North Africa.
During the next two months final plans and preparations 
would be completed for Operation Husky.

It was during this time that John Edward received his new appointment 
and wrote home that
 he was not pleased to be out of the field.

But he would go on to serve with distinction 
on Gen. Patton's staff under (then) Col. Walter Muller.
 
"After being in a tactical outfit for 2 1/2 years," he wrote that 
he felt like a "square peg in a round hole -- or should it be square head?
But so help me, I'll get out in the field again, and soon. Here's one boy 
who wants to keep on being a soldier -- not a 'Staff Officer.'"

  

It was around this time that John Edward wrote “Binnion” on an 
early version of masking tape and placed it above the 
right front pocket of his uniform.
With this aid, when someone asked his name and 
he began to stutter “B-b-b-b-b-b-b-innion,”
John Edward would say, “Lt.” and point to his last name, “Binnion.”

 (While cloth name tags or stencils were worn 
by some of the Army Paratroopers and Army Air Force Pilots, 
it wasn’t until 1953 that the Army mandated name tags for all personnel.)

 

This name tag came to the attention of Gen. Patton when 
“dad was working in a Command Tent. 
A
 message came in for Gen. Patton, who had just left. 
Dad went to the door and called, 'Hey Joe.' 
Patton came back and waved to him, and dad waited. 
Patton asked, 'Why did you call me Joe?' 
Dad said, 'Because I couldn't said G-g-g-g-g-eneral P-p-p-p-atton.'" 
John Edward Binnion II

 

Of course, General Patton's question referred mainly to 
use of the name Joe, a nickname for privates. 

But John Edward's answer was related to stuttering. 
Joe was an relatively effortless word to say: 
the soft consonant sound of J is much easier to pronounce 
than a hard consonant such as B or P; and Joe is 
a short one-syllable word, followed only by the O sound.
 

"According to the obituary in the Wichita Falls, Texas newspaper 
Times Record News, Patton liked the idea so much 
he made everyone on his staff wear one on their uniform.”
John Edward Binnion, II

 

By the second week of July, Operation Husky was ready to begin.
Soldiers began boarding ships for Sicily. 

Allied Forces board ships in preparation for Operation Husky, early July 1943, Navy photo.
 
Some 3,200 ships and vessels would carry half a million 
American and British Troops across the Mediterranean Sea.

Troops on ship headed for Sicily, July 1943, Army photo

The crossing was soon turbulent. 

Men who had been comfortable in their stacked bunks 
found their stomachs roiling along with the waves.


 
This might well have been the crossing John Edward later described to 
some family members.
 His unit had not been on a ship (the largest vessels were 
 used for Naval offensive troops and for transport of planes, tanks and other large vehicles). 
Instead, his unit was on one of the smaller vessels or 
landing craft designed to carry infantry, smaller vehicles, and cargo. 
  
43 7/Jul 10 Landing Craft of WWII diagram, Encyclopedia Britannica
 
These smaller vessels were constructed with "shallow-draft" bottoms that 
could maneuver through shallow waters and move significantly closer to a beachhead. 

But this design meant they rode not "through" waves, but "on" them. 
In rough waters, this
 resulted in jerking movements like "corks in a washing machine" 
that
 tossed and turned and rocked the vessels 30 or 40 degrees. 

Ships and vessels during a calm part of crossing the Mediterranean from North Africa to Sicily, July 8-9, 1943, Army photo.

Fierce winds stirred up waves that crashed all around the vessels. Even 
seasoned soldiers -- confined to the tightly bunked quarters -- reported that 
they found themselves seasick, many violently so.

On his initial crossing, from the United States to North Africa, 
John Edward had been required to stay below deck through rough seas. 

This time, he explained, he decided
 not to stay below while the vessel lurched its way over fierce waves. 
Up on deck he gripped the rails and watched 
as the armada traveled through thick segments of fog. 
He was on one of the last vessels in the convoy. 
Those on deck peered into the heavy fog, watching for Germans 
on patrol in the area, but unable to see more than a few feet in front of them.

At one point the fog lifted. 
John Edward said he could see a German ship, and
one of their watchmen was turning toward the Allied Armada.
 But as the German turned, the fog closed. 
The Armada had not been spotted.

John Edward took this photograph of DUKWs driving through wet sand a few months later when he was 
again in charge of a Quartermaster vehicle unit on Anzio Beachhead. January 1944, family scan. 

The high winds and relentless waves threatened havoc for the Sicily landings. 
Navy Scout Lt. Halperin explained, "everyone who knew what 
it would be like were thinking about the surf on the shore ahead 
and getting [landing] boats over side in a heavy sea." 

It would be a challenge. But Gen. Patton was prepared.

DUKWs on lined up on beach midday after landing, July 10, 1943, Royal Navy photo
 

Impressed with the newly designed amphibious DUKWs, Gen. Patton 
had ordered 1,000 for this invasion of 26 beaches along the Sicily coastline. 
They were highly effective in severe weather and turbulent waters, 
and could negotiate a smooth transition onto land. 

Without exiting the vehicle, wheels were dropped by a control inside 
the DUKW; it could then seamlessly drive onto sandy shores.
With such innovations, the landings were successful.
 

 

The headquarters for the Seventh Army were quickly
 established in central Sicily. 

Sicily Operations, Army May, July 1943, Army photo


And John Edward was given his various assignments.
"While with the G-4 Section of the Seventh Army I had several assignments, 
mostly concerned with the assignment of trucks to various parts of the Island. 
Along with this was included the daily report of available cargo vehicles to be used in 
the numerous operations on the Island, and a study to determine the maximum loads 
of ammunition, supplies, and other cargo which could safely be carried. 
(We always knew and stressed, of course, that the needs of the fighting units 
came first -- before the condition of the trucks. On more than one occasion 
this concept got me into trouble with commanding officers of some of 
the truck regiments or battalions because of too many deadlined trucks.)
"

 -- John E. Binnion, 1989


Piper Cub airplane, ca 1943, Army photo

"Later, Col. Muller asked me to be the Seventh Army Air Courier 
to carry messages and other Secret and Classified papers 
from the Seventh Army in Palermo to the 'other' headquarters
 on the other side of the Island.

"These flights occurred in Piper Cub planes which were
 generally piloted by an artillery spotter, and the flights required me to fly 
with classified documents from Headquarters, Seventh Army, to the 
southern part of the Island where I turned the documents over to American
 and British Commanding Officers. We then flew back to Seventh Army 
Headquarters with the follow-up answers, documents, or other information."
John E. Binnion, 1989 


Carrying a pilot and one passenger, the Piper Cub planes, also 
known as L-4 Grasshoppers, were nicknamed "flying jeeps." 
These small unarmed planes were largely used for battle observation, 
transport, and communication.

Piper Plane in air over Sicily, July - August 1943, Army photo
  

"In flying from Palermo to the Gela/Licata Headquarters our 
Piper Cub was attacked two times by a German pursuit plane, 
but managed to escape without harm. 

On these trips I also had the opportunity to meet and/or see 
some of the big names of that part of World War II including 
the British Generals Alexander and Montgomery."

John E. Binnion, 1989 

Sir Bernard Montgomery and Gen. George Patton near Palermo, Sicily, 
July 28 1943, Army photo

It was during these months in Sicily that Gen. Patton, while visiting 
evacuation hospitals, berated and slapped two soldiers for 
what was then called "battle fatigue" or "shell shock."

When Gen. Eisenhower received reports from the doctors he ordered 
an investigation, then privately admonished Patton and had him apologize 
to the soldiers and troops. But he asked the media to withhold the information, 
and explained that the military needed Patton's expertise. 

Gen. Patton giving one of his apologizes to officers and troops, Sicily, 
August 1943, photo 45th Infantry Division, Army

The information, however, was reported by radio commentator 
Drew Pearson on November 21 of that year. 

 In a February 1944 letter home (written from Anzio), John Edward wrote 
about the news and expressed his high opinion of Gen. Patton.

John Edward letter home written from Anzio, Italy during February of 1944, family scan 

"I'm very sorry that all the publicity about Gen. Patton got out to the Public. 
We knew about it over in Sicily last August, but we hoped that it would be hushed. 
He is really a wonderful man, and one of his idiosyncrasies is popping off at times like that
 when in reality it is just his sincerity and enthusiasm coming to the front. 
He is a magnificent field General, and in my opinion is just as smart as almost any of our Generals."  

 

To complete the conquest of Sicily, the Allies needed to take Messina, 
the main port with mainland Italy. The American 7th Army under Patton 
and the British 8th Army under Montgomery drove northwest for several weeks. 
They pushed relentlessly through Axis forces and entered Messina on the 17th of September.   

 American troops in Messina, August 17, 1943, Army photo

 "Made the invasion of (South) Italy (Messina) in September of 1943."
John E. Binnion, Military History 

 

Years later, when a report on Op Husky and operations in Sicily 
was "unclassified," John Edward requested a copy of the document.
He is listed under Transportation Section -- Base Area.

Report of Operations of the United States Seventh Army in the Sicilian Campaign, 10 July - 17 August 1943, family scan

   

"After the cessation of hostilities in Sicily, I asked to be transferred 
to the field and specifically asked to join the 1st Ranger Battalion .... 
However, because of a back operation which had been performed 
at the 6th General Hospital in Casablanca, I was 
turned down for some physical reasons."
John E. Binnion, 1989 

Officer's Pay Card dated May 30, 1944 for 1st Lt. John Edward, back in 
the Quartermaster Corps,
 was issued for pay period ending September 16, 1943, family scan

"I was given approval to join Company D, 53rd QM Bn (DUKW)." 
John E. Binnion, 1989

   

Thanks for reading. 
You may find the previous post here. 
And join us soon for the next post. 

 

John Edward Binnion: 22: Operation Torch D-Day

 
 
The 4,000 mile diversionary circuitous route of 107,000 American and British
 troops across the Atlantic was successful. 
 
Some 350 warships, 500 transport ships and other vessels, 
and 1,000 planes, arrived at their rendezvous point near Gibraltar. 
 
Undetected.
 
 
It was D-Day for Operation Torch:
The invasion of western North Africa where territory was
 defended not by Italian or German troops, but 
by Vichy French Forces who made a deal with Hitler.
  
US Convoy nearing Casablanca, Dawn on November 8, 1942, US Navy
 
One third of the fleet assembled about eight miles* off the Atlantic coast 
of Casablanca. An American fleet of 102 transport ships with 35,000  troops 
was accompanied by Navy warships and minesweepers. 
 
This was the Western Task Force, under Gen. George Patton.

They were to be the first to land, and were to
secure three beachheads near Casablanca, Morocco.

Operation Torch Allied Invasion Map, November 8, 1942, Army Map
 
Once those were secured, the other two Task Forces would begin to land
at Oran and Algiers beachheads along the Mediterranean Sea
.
 
Bomber is loaded on the USS Ranger, November 8, 1942, Army Photo
 
Well before dawn, virtually every soldier and sailor were finalizing operations.

Warships with aircraft were readied by the Navy and the Army Air Forces; 
they 
would secure Safi harbor south of Casablanca 
and then support Infantry landings on all three beaches.
  
 
Specialized Army landing forces hoisted jeeps, trucks, 
tanks, artillery, and combat supplies onto ramped transport vessels 
and prepared to ferry them ashore. 


Transfer from ship to landing craft; soldiers climb down a ladder 
while a crate is lowered by cable, November 8, 1942, Army photo
 
 
And each soldier 
geared up with the field 
supply belts, weapons,
 and backpacks 
as they had when training. 
 
2nd Lt. John Edward
and his troops 
would now face 
their first battle.
 
As would 80% 
of the 35,000 
Western Task Force 
soldiers.
 
The men 
clambered down ladders 
or scaled cargo nets 
while crates of 
combat equipment 
were lowered onto 
nearby vessels.
 
One by one, 
John Edward
and his men
moved from the ship
to a landing craft.
 
 
 
 
When filled with about thirty soldiers, 
the craft left ship side and crested its first wave. 
 
With the heavy swells on that morning, 
many of the small vessels immediately faced waters 
that rose and crashed over them.  
   
Landing craft faces rough waters as it departs ship for beach, November 8, 1942, Army photo still
  
They would motor for several hours through these ocean waters, 
 traveling the eight to twelve miles to their next 
rendezvous points along the Atlantic Coast of Morocco.
 
Landing craft and ship near Safi, November 8, 1942, National Archives
 
Each group of landing craft were accompanied by 
Navy destroyers and minesweepers. 
 
 
Reaching the lines of departure, they were some 4,000 yards 
offshore. Another 15-20 minutes away.
The first wave of the Western Task Force was ready.
 
 
Just outside Safi Harbor, her mast removed for this operation, 
the destroyer-transport USS Bernadou led the way.
 
USS Bernadou, Operation Torch, Navy photo

For this battle there were to be no preparatory and protective 
air or naval bombardments: 

Gen. Eisenhower had ordered Americans 
not to fire unless fired upon.
Following months of Allied Intelligence among the Vichy French, 
stationed in North Africa,
it was just possible that their Navy would give
no more than token resistance and then join the Allies.


Battleships near Casablanca beaches, November 8, 1942, National Archives
 
USS Bernadou entered Safi harbor at 4:28 am. 
 
With some commanders still loyal to Germany, 
the French Vichy navy and shore battery were ordered to open fire. 
And "all hell broke loose."
 
 
Amidst counter-fire, the USS Bernadou barrelled on and charged 
full-speed toward the boom, the harbor's steel-mesh defense barrier. 
With her machine guns and anti-aircraft guns 
sweeping the Safi docks, the Captain 
rammed the ship into the sand and beached there. 
 
USS Bernadou rammed into sand at Safi Harbor, November 8, 1942, Navy photo
 
Still under fire, 197 soldiers trained in night-raiding descended the 
landing net and set off for their counter-sabotage work in Safi. 
The remaining infantry units on that ship immediately followed. 
 
 American troops were on North African soil.
 
Allied counter-fire continued, and the Vichy French Navy was
 soon pushed back. But then sniper fire began. 

F4F-4 Wildcat fighter taking of from USS Ranger, November 8, 1942, National Archives
 
Since Allied Naval guns had little inland visibility in the 
early dawn darkness and cloud cover, aircraft began to take off.
 
On all three Western Task Force beaches,  
24 bombers and fighter planes supported the remaining 
35,000 troops
 as they approached the beachheads.
  
Troops wade toward beach from lowered boat ramps, November 8, 1942, National Archives
 
When a landing craft reached shallow water, 
troops waded in from their boats. 

Tanks and other amphibious vehicles drove off the ramps
of their Higgins Boats and directly onto the beaches.
 
 
Infantry land on a beachhead near Casablanca; there is a tank in back left and a 
ramped landing craft in center; November 8, 1942, National Archives
   

Naval and ground fighting continued throughout the morning. 
However, Gen. Patton wrote in his diary that day: 

"I feel that most of the time they bomb the ocean
 rather than the beach."
 
Vichy French bombs land in water near ship approaching beach near Casablanca, 
November 8, 1942, Army film still

Erratic shelling was one more indication that Allied Intelligence
had laid a solid foundation for cooperation with the Vichy French. 
Both officers and soldiers were reluctant to fight troops
they saw more as liberators than enemies. 
  
 Ammunition for light guns unloaded from a landing craft, November 8, 1942, Navy photo
 
By late afternoon, ammunition, weapons, and medical supplies 
were ferried to the northern and southern beachheads. 
T
hey were secured some 5,000 yards by evening. 
 
But landings were delayed at Fedala, the middle beachhead 
of the Western Task Force.
 
Rough waters and waves that reached fifteen feet destroyed 
or damaged over 100 boats when winds 
and waves capsized or crashed them onto rocky beaches.
  
 
Meanwhile, landings had commenced 
along the Mediterranean Coast near Oran and Algeria. 
Near Oran, the Central Task Force faced French Vichy defenses 
for two days before the city was captured. 
 
Operation Torch diagram, US Navy
 

The Eastern Task Force landings near Algiers, however, faced little opposition. 

Free French and Algerian resistance forces who had infiltrated 
the area were soon helping unload weapons and supplies, 
and the city was under Allied control by nightfall. 

Algerians help Eastern Task Force unload petrol, November 8, 1942, British News film still

By D+1, November 9, the French Naval fleet was virtually destroyed.  
Land battles, however, continued throughout the next two days.
 
 
For the Western Task Force, fighting would next focus 
on the capture of Casablanca. 
Lt. John Edward and his men landed 
on one of those three beachheads near Casablanca:  
"Made the Invasion of North Africa, Casablanca."
--John Edward Binnion Military History, ca 1998 
 
  This was most likely at the Fedala Beachhead,
 where the mass of support vehicles, equipment, and supplies 
were to be delivered by the Quartermaster Corps.
These accompanied the bulk of the infantry, who were 
also to land at Fedala and then march on the city of Casablanca. 
 
Artillery hauled up to Fedala beachhead, November 8 or 9, 1942, Army photo

 But rough surf delayed landings at Fedala throughout D-Day and D+1. 
As a result, by midday November 9, less than half of 
those troops were ashore, 
and even less of the combat cargo.  
 
Soldiers guard a transport craft stuck in sand on the Fedala rocky shoreline, November 8-9, 1942 Army photo
  
 What equipment and supplies had been delivered were scattered 
amidst a number of the landing craft
 stuck in the sand. 
Fo
r those who had landed, it was a couple of cold damp nights. 
Soldiers who guarded landing craft, vehicles, and supplies, had only 
detritus for improvised blanket-warmth on the beach.
 
They worked through the 9th and into the 10th freeing craft, 
consolidating the combat equipment and supplies, and 
organizing trucks and jeeps as they landed. 
 
  
 Shortly after noon on the 9th, Patton came ashore at Fedala.
 
Patton on landing craft heading for his first visit to Fedala beachhead, November 9, 1942, Army photo. 
(Photo note: Sgt. George Meeks looks up from center; while the Army was segregated during WWII, Patton brought Sgt. Meeks onto his personal staff.) 
  
Later that day his troops started toward Casablanca and closed in
 on the 10th. They were prepared to attack on the 11th, but the city 
surrendered first. Later that day an armistice was signed.

 
With an armistice signed, U.S. Army tank peacefully drives into Casablanca, 
November 11, 1942, National Archives

 

With the successful launch of Operation Torch, 
there were a number of strategic advantages for the Allies.

They now controlled trade and transport 
throughout the Mediterranean Sea -- essential for the upcoming European Campaign.
And from Northeastern North Africa, where they would soon march to take 
Tunisia, they would be in position to invade Sicily. 
From there, they would enter the European Campaign 
through Italy, "the soft underbelly of Europe." 

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill famously coined such expressions. 
Regarding Operation Torch, the beginning of the North African Campaign, he said:
"Now this is not the end.
It is not even the beginning to the end.
But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning."

 
 

*More information can be found in Operation Torch, prepared by the US Navy. 
Additional background and stories are readily available on sites such as 
the National Army Museum or the Warfare History Network. 


Thanks for reading.
Find the previous post here. 
And join us here for the next post.