John Edward Binnion: 10: The Louisiana Maneuvers, Part 1

  
In 1941, General George Marshall began the largest
military training and preparedness exercises in American History--the Louisiana Maneuvers. 

The purpose?

General George Marshall called these maneuvers a 
"combat college for troop training" 
a testing ground to evaluate leadership skills of both 
current and rising officers, and a "field laboratory" to test 
newer modernized weapons, artillery, and tanks.
It would be difficult to overstate the importance of this training.

Convoy on way to Louisiana Maneuvers, August 1941, Army photo

 During the early days of
August 1941, t
roops from 19 Divisions
and 10 Army-Navy Air Groups
set out for the

Louisiana Maneuvers.

Nearly half a million men
were accompanied by tens of thousands 
of army
tanks, trucks, jeeps,
weapons, ammunition, and food supplies. 

Of the seemingly endless convoys
and trainloads of soldiers,
John Edward and his Company
were just a handful.

 

Marshall personally observed many of the maneuvers and explained:
“I want the mistakes made in Louisiana, not made in Europe.
If it doesn’t work, find out what we need to do to make it work”  

 

Small tanks cross a pontoon bridge built by the Army engineers, 1941, Army photo
    

In mid-July Army engineers built roads and bridges,
depots to store the millions of tons of ammunition (blanks), flour,
and coffee, and barracks to accommodate many of the troops.
Thousands of Louisianans assisted, contributing to depression relief throughout the state.

 


The maneuvers covered 20 million acres
that the government secured from
almost 100,000 landowners. 


A week before the maneuvers began,
a hurricane caused havoc
for the engineers,
who continued their work along
slippery and muddy roads.
And the exponential increase
of chiggers, ticks, and
other biting insects
tortured the already hot,
sticky, sweaty soldiers
all around the 40 by 90 mile area.

 

Every aspect of the maneuvers was designed to be intense
and physically demanding.
Arriving at camp, the troops continued preparation begun by the
Army engineers. "We dug garbage pits and drainage pits (6 x 6 x 6) in
the hardest clay you ever saw. It takes 3 men all day to dig one of them."  (10 Aug)

 

Letter home, Louisiana Maneuvers, August 10, 1941, family scan

For John Edward, physical exhaustion was compounded
by the Army's unrelenting 
disregard of him because of his stuttering. With
every letter written during July we saw an escalation of

deep discouragement and utter frustration.

John Edward referred to this, and to the recent extension of military service by Congress,
when he wrote: "it's enough to make a man want to 'go over the hill.'"
This new slang term was a protest made by
soldiers who
threatened desertion when their original one-year commitment of service ended.

 

Field Artillery, Louisiana Maneuvers, 1941, Army photo
In his next letter John Edward began:
"Goody, goody, hot dog, we won the war." (20 Aug)
It was the first of two mock battles,

one in August and one in September.

Troops were trained in offensive and defensive
combat, infantry tactics, and battlefield situations
designed to address increasingly difficult
tests and specific "problems,"
such as
how to move troops across a river, how to seize a specific target, or how to move an armored force
over extremely rough terrain.

 
Flour bombs were dropped from airplanes, blanks were used as ammunition
for those who had weapons, and others held signs to indicate a weapon.
Some trucks had "TANK" painted on the sides, and drainpipe was
attached to others to simulate anti-tank guns.

"Rules governing engagement and 'casualties' were established. Battles took place
on lawns, in private yards, on town streets, and in surrounding forests.
Truces were declared at lunchtime so that soldiers could eat. Hundreds of 'umpires,'
armed with clipboards and armbands, assessed units and leaders
according to a complex grading system and ruled on how many soldiers
were 'killed or injured.' Monitoring the time it took medical units to
transfer the 'wounded' to combat hospitals was also important."
(Sharp School online curriculum guide for the Louisiana Maneuvers)

 
 The good humor of the August 20 letter addressed to "Folksies"
continued with whimsical reflections on nearby towns,
on ham for breakfast, dinner, supper, and snacks,
and on the rescue attempt of
a piglet.
 
 
 
 But solemn words were also written:

"If you can think up a good way
to get me out of the Army,
wire, don't write.
2 1/2 years is at least 2 1/2 years too long to
spend in the Army--as a pvt." (20 Aug)
 
 
With his stuttering,
John Edward has been passed over for promotion at every point.
A striking difference from repeated
stunning successes and recognition in younger years.
"The Army's extreme prejudice to this affliction
brought him to one of his lowest periods."
John Edward II, September 2024

 
 
Thanks for reading.
Join us for the next post here.



John Edward Binnion: 9: Back at Camp Bowie

 

Camp Bowie, Field Artillery Training, Army photo
 

 Back at Camp Bowie,
John Edward wrote a post script at the bottom of his July 6 letter:


With typical wit John Edward summed up his frame of mind.
This, and every letter written from Camp Bowie during July,
reveal deepening
concern for his ambitions:
promotion, and opportunity to attend Officer Candidate School.

 

Disregarded and overlooked for promotion over and over and again,
John Edward met once more with cousin Col. Caviness. 
He then wrote home:
"We spent almost all of our
conversation on that one subject:"
  Stuttering

Letter home, July 6, 1941, family scan

Escalation of John Edward's frustration is apparent in these letters.
And over the months to come we will see how
"the Army's
extreme prejudice to this affliction
brought him to one of his lowest periods."
John Edward Binnion, II, September 22, 2024
 

 

And then news reached camp: 
Congress voted
to extend service beyond the one year enlistment. 

Letter home, July 11, 1941, family scan

In earlier letters we alternately saw
anticipation and discouragement.
But now,
the threat of three years without promotion loomed
for John Edward with tremendous weight.  


At the same time, he was able to keep in mind two things that
were of key importance throughout his life: a sense of humor
and loved ones (at that time Ruth, his girlfriend from Austin).

Letter home, July 11, 1941, family scan


With this wit and humor, he asked about how things were
with his parents: "How is your mouth mother?
Hope you are feeling better.
When do we get the new 'store teeth'?" (11 Jul)

 

During the following five days John Edward and some of his friends
were out on furlough.

Letter home, July 17, 1941, family scan


Which did not alter his low spirit. 
However, training soon absorbed every moment.

Letter home, July 22, 1941, family scan

And the Louisiana Maneuvers were about to begin. The
largest maneuvers in the history of the United States
would soon take the attention of virtually every officer and soldier in the Army.
 

Sending a mailing address for the next two months, John Edward
also wrote the following note about assistance for his parents.

Letter home, July 31, 1941, family scan  

 While $20 does not seem like much today, his parents were
still recovering from the Depression, and it would have covered
about $450 (with inflation, over $2,000 today) of the needed dental work.
Once again, whatever the personal exasperation,
his eye was on the larger picture.

 


Thanks for reading.
Join us for the next post where the 36th Division
takes part in the Louisiana Maneuvers.